Home Insurance What Happens if Liability Insurance Can’t Cover My Lawsuit Settlement?

What Happens if Liability Insurance Can’t Cover My Lawsuit Settlement?

3 Minutes read
What Happens if Liability Insurance Can't Cover My Lawsuit Settlement? Learn about coverage limitations and steps to take for business protection.

If your liability insurance falls short in covering your lawsuit settlement, your insurance company’s responsibility is limited to the damages outlined within the policy’s limits.

From our years of experience, if the damages exceed the policy limits, you may be responsible for paying the remaining amount out of pocket.

However, if the other party sues you for an amount exceeding your insurance coverage, your insurance provider isn’t obligated to cover any damages beyond your policy’s limits.

Consequently, you may need to take legal action against the other party to seek compensation from their assets, which can include savings accounts, additional vehicles, etc.

Sounds complicated?

Don’t worry; we’ll equip you with the knowledge and strategies needed to tackle this legal dilemma head-on.

Read on.

What Does Liability Insurance Cover?

Business liability insurance covers several risks and potential liabilities your business may encounter.

This type of insurance protects you against claims and lawsuits arising from bodily injury, property damage, or personal injury caused by your business operations, products, or services.

It typically covers legal expenses, medical costs, and settlements.

Also, business liability insurance can cover advertising injuries, such as copyright infringement or defamation, including instances of professional negligence.

Business Liability Insurance is important if you want to safeguard your firm’s financial stability and mitigate the potential risks associated with legal claims and liabilities.

You may also like: Professional Liability Insurance for Dentists: Everything You Need to Know

Limitations of Liability Insurance

Business liability insurance, while valuable, does have its limitations.

Based on our experience in the insurance niche, here are some important limitations to be aware of:

Coverage Gaps

Your business liability insurance may not cover all potential risks and liabilities specific to your business operations or industry.

You may need specialized coverage for certain circumstances, such as professional errors or cyber-related incidents, through separate policies.

Policy Limits

Every liability insurance policy has predefined coverage limits.

If a claim exceeds these limits, you may need to cover the remaining costs out of pocket.

Hence, we recommend carefully assessing your coverage needs and ensuring that the policy limits align with your potential risks.

Policy Exclusions

Policies often have specific exclusions that outline circumstances your insurance doesn’t cover.

These exclusions can vary but often include contractual liabilities, intentional acts, or certain high-risk activities.

You must carefully evaluate these exclusions to avoid coverage gaps.


Deductibles are the amount you must pay out of pocket before the insurance coverage activates.

Your business liability insurance will typically include deductibles, but keep in mind that high deductibles can impact your ability to cover immediate expenses in the event of a claim.

Retroactive Dates

Some liability policies may have retroactive dates, meaning they only cover claims that arise after a specific date.

Your insurance may not cover claims related to incidents that occurred prior to the retroactive date.

Policy Premiums

Business liability insurance comes with premiums that you must pay regularly for continuous coverage.

Premiums can vary based on factors like the size of your business, industry risk, and your claims history.

We recommend budgeting for these ongoing expenses.

The above are the limitations your business liability insurance might have.

We advise that you understand them and plan for them accordingly.

Acknowledging these limitations will help you make informed decisions about your coverage, consider additional policies or risk management strategies, and ensure you have comprehensive protection for your business.

We also recommend consulting with an experienced insurance professional to assess your specific needs and tailor your coverage accordingly.

What to do If Liability Insurance Falls Short

If your liability insurance falls short of covering a claim, you must assess the coverage gap first. Evaluate the extent to which your liability insurance falls short in covering the claim.

Understand the financial implications and potential risks involved.

Drawing from our experience in the insurance niche, here are some other crucial  steps to take when your liability falls short:

Consult with Your Insurance Provider

Contact your insurance provider to discuss the situation.

In some cases, they may be able to offer guidance or potential solutions to help bridge the coverage gap.

Always keep your legal counselor within arm’s reach.

Seek advice from an experienced attorney specializing in liability matters.

They can review your insurance policy, assess the claim, and provide guidance on legal options available to you.

Negotiate with Involved Parties

Negotiating with the claimant or their legal representatives can help you explore possible resolutions.

Reaching a settlement agreement or alternative resolution may benefit both parties involved depending on the circumstances.

Consider Self-Funding

If the coverage gap is manageable and within your means, you may choose to self-fund the remaining amount.

However, carefully weigh the potential financial impact and consider the long-term implications before taking action.

Explore Additional Funding Sources

While self-funding is smart when your insurance liability falls short, but you may not always have access to the required funding.

In such situations, consider alternative funding sources.

This may include seeking financing, tapping into business reserves, or engaging in discussions with financial institutions to secure the necessary funds.

Review and Adjust Coverage

Use this experience as an opportunity to reassess your liability insurance coverage. Consult with your insurance professional to determine if adjustments or additional coverage options are necessary to prevent similar gaps in the future.

Remember, each situation is unique, and seeking advice from professionals well-versed in insurance and legal matters is vital.

By taking prompt action, engaging in open communication, and leveraging the expertise of experts, you can navigate the challenges that arise when liability insurance falls short and work towards a satisfactory resolution.

Recommended for you: Insuring Your New York Real Estate Business: A Guide

How to Avoid Insufficient Liability Insurance Coverage

As a business owner, avoiding insufficient liability insurance coverage is crucial to protect your company adequately. Here are some strategies to consider, drawing on experience in the insurance niche:

Regularly Assess Coverage Needs

Evaluate your business operations, industry-specific risks, and potential liabilities.

Conducting periodic assessments will help you understand the changing landscape of your business and determine if your current liability coverage is still adequate.

Work with an Experienced Insurance Professional

By now, you might’ve noticed how often I stress the need to consult an experienced insurance professional in your industry.

Well, your business’s insurance is a sensitive situation that may require actions in unfamiliar situations.

Hence, you need an insurance professional in your industry that can guide you through the process of assessing your coverage needs and help you choose appropriate liability insurance policies that align with your business requirements.

A professional can also help you in situations when your insurance company won’t settle claim.

Understand Policy Limits and Exclusions

There’s no better way to understand your coverage limits and exclusions than reviewing your insurance policy.

It’ll help you identify potential gaps and make informed decisions about securing adequate coverage.

Consider Umbrella or Excess Liability Insurance

Consider obtaining an umbrella liability insurance policy if your business faces higher liability risks.

These policies offer an extra layer of protection by providing additional coverage beyond the limits of your primary liability policies.

Stay Informed about Industry Regulations and Lawsuits

Always stay updated on relevant industry regulations and legal trends.

Understanding emerging risks and common liability claims within your niche can help you assess the potential impact on your business and adjust your insurance coverage accordingly.

Implement Risk Management Strategies

Did you know you can lower your insurance premiums by implementing effective strategies?

This works by reducing your risk level, thus encouraging your insurer to lower the premiums you pay.

You can do this by implementing comprehensive strategies, such as safety protocols, employee training programs, and proper documentation practices.

These will help reduce potential hazards.

I’ll conclude this section by encouraging you to take a proactive approach to evaluate and secure appropriate liability insurance coverage to protect your business from potential financial setbacks better and ensure you have the necessary resources to handle any unforeseen liabilities.

Related Post: Can Your Business Insurance Company Deny Renewal?

Wrapping it up

Overall, it is crucial for business owners to address potential gaps in liability insurance coverage.

Regularly assess your coverage needs, work with experienced insurance professionals, and stay informed about industry regulations.

When faced with insufficient coverage, we recommend consulting with your insurance provider, engaging legal counsel, and exploring negotiation and funding options.

Also, remember to review and adjust your coverage, implement risk management strategies, and take a proactive approach to protect your business.

These measures help you prepare for and navigate liability insurance challenges and safeguard your business’s financial stability.

Recommended For You: Free Business Templates to Streamline Your Workflow this New Year

Hand-Picked For You:


Can Liability Insurance Fully Cover a Lawsuit Settlement?

Yes, business liability insurance can fully cover a lawsuit settlement up to the policy’s coverage limits, including costs.

However, if the settlement amount exceeds the coverage limits, you may be responsible for paying the remaining amount.

Can You Settle an Insurance Claim Without a Lawyer?

Yes, settling an insurance claim without a lawyer is possible, especially for simple cases with minor damages or injuries.

In such situations, you can communicate directly with the insurance company, provide the necessary documentation, and negotiate a settlement.

However, seeking legal advice may be beneficial for complex claims or disputes.

Who Pays for Damages that Exceed the Policy Limit?

The policyholder pays for damages that exceed the policy limit

Your insurance company will only cover costs up to the specified limit in the insurance policy.

What Determines the Coverage Limit of My Liability Insurance Policy?

Your coverage type, insurer’s guidelines, your desired level of protection, and associated premiums determine the coverage limit of your liability insurance policy.

These factors collectively contribute to establishing the coverage limit for your liability insurance policy.

How Can I Prevent Coverage Gaps?

You can prevent coverage gaps by: 

  • Regularly reviewing and updating your insurance policies
  • Understanding policy exclusions
  • Working with an experienced insurance professional, and
  • Considering additional coverage options to address specific risks or changes in your business operations.


  • Jared Ogboriefor

    Jared is a seasoned insurance blogger with years of experience in the industry. He is passionate about providing valuable information to individuals and businesses. His extensive knowledge of various insurance-related topics, including auto insurance, home insurance, life insurance, business insurance and more, is a testament to his expertise.

Other Recommended Posts

Smart Entrepreneur Blog

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More